Skip to content

Elements versus Photoshop – which is best? Tell us what you think…

Categories

Featured Products

box_photoshop_cs4_90x90 Elements versus Photoshop - which is best? Tell us what you think... Photography & Photoshop News Polls box_pse7_90x90 Elements versus Photoshop - which is best? Tell us what you think... Photography & Photoshop News Polls elements-versus-photoshop Elements versus Photoshop - which is best? Tell us what you think... Photography & Photoshop News Polls box_lightroom2_90x90 Elements versus Photoshop - which is best? Tell us what you think... Photography & Photoshop News Polls

[poll id=”18″]
elements-versus-photoshop Elements versus Photoshop - which is best? Tell us what you think... Photography & Photoshop News Polls

Here are a few questions I get asked in emails on a daily basis:

– Should I buy Elements or Full Photoshop? If I am just starting out as a photographer which should I get? If I am building a portrait business which should I get?

– Why do most of your Photoshop Actions only work in Photoshop (not Elements)?

– What are the differences in Elements and Photoshop, and why is Photoshop significantly more money?

Now I will explain, from my perspective, answers to these questions.

Photoshop is a very powerful product, designed for photographers and digital artists alike.  It is capable of doing almost anything you can imagine to a photograph, if the artist knows how to properly use the program.  Photoshop has been around a long time.  A new version usually comes out every year and a half or so.

Each version has a number.  After they got to Photoshop 7 (not the same as the new Elements 7), they started grouping Photoshop with the Creative Suite.  And Photoshop CS was born (AKA version 8).  From there CS2 (version 9), then CS3 (version 10) and the most current is CS4 (version 11).  So on my site if I say an action works in Photoshop 7+, this means Photoshop 7 and then CS-CS4.  It does not mean Elements 7.

Elements is basically a striped down Photoshop (with a few novelty items added back).  To visualize, picture Photoshop as a car.  If you have luxury car, and take away the leather seats, sunroof, power windows and door locks, cruise control, and the fancier engine – you have Elements.

It is limited in that it is missing some of the key editing tools which make Photoshop an industry leader.  These tools are why most of my Photoshop Actions do not work in Elements.  In order for an action to work, the program needs to have the commands and tools used in the action.  So if an action calls upon the full curves, channel mixers, lab mode, or a filter that is not available, etc – it will NOT work in Elements since Elements does not have any idea what it is being told to do.

As far as versions, Elements in now on version 7 – so remember Elements 7 is not the same as Photoshop 7 (an old full version of Photoshop).

So which do you need:

Elements can do most basic editing.  If you are a hobbiest who wants to digitally scrapbook, brighten up your photos, and make your photos better, Elements may be a great choice.  Elements also has some added goodies not in Photoshop that make editing faster and easier, but more automatic and less controlled.

If you are an amateur or professional photographer, or just LOVE playing with your photos and having all the tools available for you at your fingertips, buy Photoshop.  Nothing compares. But only buy it if you are going to learn to use it.  Once you really get to know Photoshop you will be in awe.  I cannot imagine life without full Photoshop.  I did start with Elements but after a few months felt like it was missing something.

The cost factor….  Photoshop costs significantly more than Elements.  You need to decide if it provides enough value to you and your life and/or business. If you are a student, there are discounts available. And occasionally you can find an older version clearanced out (for example now CS3).  Do beware, if a deal sounds too good to be true, it may be.  I have seen many buy on eBay at dirt cheap prices only to find out adobe will not support their product and that it is missing certain things when running.

I hope this helped some of you have a better idea of which fits your needs best. I would love to hear which you have, which you want and why?  Please take my poll and add to the comments below. (Notice I have Lightroom and Raw Editors listed in the poll – but that I did not discuss them here – I wanted to let those who edit in Raw exclusively vote – but this post itself is about elements versus photoshop).

Thank you,

Jodi

MCPActions

No Comments

  1. Andie on October 18, 2008 at 2:30 pm

    Jodi – I’m Interested!!! Please oh please, I’m dying for the quickie collection but use elements, I’ll upgrade if you make them!!!! THANK YOU! You are the best! Andie

  2. Jenney on October 19, 2008 at 9:13 am

    I’m going to buy Elements 7 this afternoon. I’d DEFINITELY be interested if you can covert your actions to Elements 7!!! Thank you, thank you!!!

  3. Emily on October 20, 2008 at 7:51 am

    I would love more actions for Elements. I am a hobbyist and Elements has served my needs, but I love your Eye Dr./Dentist actions and would love to be able to use more. I would def. buy more actions for Elements!

  4. Andie on October 20, 2008 at 10:13 am

    Jodi – I think PE7.0 is just for PC users…correct? I’m a mac user and PE6 is the latest version…still interested if Adobe plans to upgrade the mac one…thanks!

  5. JoAnne on October 20, 2008 at 12:18 pm

    Jodi…any chance you can make your magic skin actions available for Elements users? Thanks!

  6. admin on October 20, 2008 at 1:04 pm

    JoAnne – there is no way for me to make that happen unfortunately as it uses many features only available in big photoshop.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Categories

Recent Posts

Scroll To Top